Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
All American Burger
Original Fresh Cut
Boneless Wings
Soft Pretzelsticks
About
Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery
Welcome to Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery, a hidden gem located at 105 Allen St, Tiffin, OH 44883. This bustling eatery offers more than just good food; it provides an exceptional dining experience that combines comfort and flavor. With a menu bursting with mouthwatering options, from the classic All American Burger to the adventurous Chili Burger, there’s something for every palate.
The fresh cut fries are a must-try, especially the Cheesy Bacon Fries and the fun Bacon Cheesy & More Bacon Burger. Each dish comes in generous portions, ensuring that you're not just satisfied, but utterly delighted, just like customer Scott Barnes, who praised his experience with the cowboy burger and cheese fries for being simply "amazing."
Benchwarmers truly excels in creating a welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the friendly staff and immaculate cleanliness of the restaurant. Cathy Morris highlighted the wide variety of options, from refreshing Greek salads to delightful chicken wraps, all crafted with care. The daily specials, including throwbacks to the beloved cutlet sandwich from the previous Alpine Tavern, keep the locals and visitors alike coming back for more.
What truly sets Benchwarmers apart is the synergy of great food and camaraderie. The vibe is perfect for families looking to enjoy a meal together, or for friends gathering to catch a game, with an abundance of TVs adorning the walls. Steve Hayes lauded the service and atmosphere as ideal for a post-soccer gathering, reinforcing the restaurant’s reputation as a local cornerstone.
In addition to the exceptional food, the beverages don't fall short. Refreshing house-made lemonade, iced tea, and fruit punch pair perfectly with your meal, enhancing the overall dining experience. Whether you choose to dine in or take advantage of their delivery service, Benchwarmers offers an unforgettable encounter at every turn.
With each visit, you’ll find that the flavors echo the warm welcomes from the staff. Come experience the magic of Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery yourself. It's worth the trip off the beaten path, just as Shelby Miller and many others have discovered, proving that great food and service are just a burger's throw away!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ From out of state, looked at the menu and we were hooked. Top notch food, and portions. Got a cowboy burger and cheese fries....amazing experience. Highly recommend them. ”
“ I've had several items on the menu and they have all been great. Greek salad, tomato bisque, chicken wrap, perch and the burgers are really good. The staff is friendly and accommodating. Very clean. They offer a different special every day. One of them is the cutlet sandwich that was the specialty of the previous Alpine Tavern. They offer delivery. Worth the trip off of the beaten path. ”
“ My family and I were on road and decided to try out the benchwarmer’s restaurant! The service was amazing and they stayed on top of everything! The food was incredible as well. All around a very wonderful environment! ”
“ We had Brady as our waiter, and he was such a sweet heart and gave great service! The food was amazing as well, and came very fast! ”
“ Great little place with as many TVs as it has tables, very friendly local. Simple food done well great service by willing waitresses, eaten twice both good, once just popped in for post soccer beers from Tiffin university, recommended, will be back. Good value with daily specials. ”
“ It's a small pub and not a lot of tables . I didn't expect it to be so crowded during the middle of the week for lunch but after getting our food I understand why. For the prices it was pretty cheap the kids meals were just enough and they ate it all and said it was good. The wings were yummy and they said the hamburgers and chicken chunks were good. The wait time was long but it was worth it. The waitress deserves a raise for her effort on waiting and serving all the tables by herself. Probably the cook also. Go try it out the menu was a lot of stuff and if I didn't live 1 hour and 40 minutes away I would go there often. The fries are like fair Fry's so yummy the bowl was a large we shared between 4 of us . Bone in wings price varies ours was 8.99 for 6 . They also had larger portions. What was great is you can order single burgers double and triple. Just go and try it . It was Worth it ”
“ I get a smaller Bdubs vibe from here. But their portions here at Benchwarmers is definitely bigger. The food is always good when we go. Service was great as well. ”
“ Great place for burgers. They are delicious. Variety of French fry options and soft pretzels better than any other I've had. ”